Games & Gaming

Best Asymmetric Multiplayer Horror Games for PS5 and Xbox

A curated selection of asymmetric horror titles available on PS5 and Xbox Series X/S where one player assumes the role of a hunter or monster while others defend or survive. These games offer unique social dynamics, intense psychological tension, and replayable gameplay loops that differ significantly from traditional co-op horror experiences.

ID: 1000038
Items: 20
Total Votes: 0
Forks: 0
Disclosure: Some links are affiliate links. If you buy through them, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you, supporting our work without affecting our ratings.
Want to feature your product on this list?
Sponsorship

Get targeted exposure with custom position pinning and highlighted placement.

Contact Us
1
0

Dead by Daylight

Visit

The definitive asymmetric horror experience featuring four survivors versus one deadly killer. With a vast roster of licensed and original characters, cross-play support, and regular updates, it remains the gold standard for this genre on modern consoles.

2
0

Evil Dead: The Game

Visit

Based on the iconic film franchise, this title lets players embody Ash Williams or various monsters like the Kandarian Demons. It features unique character abilities and a brutal melee combat system that distinguishes it from competitors in the genre.

3
0

The Nightmare Before Christmas: Oogie's Revenge

Visit

While primarily a single-player action game, note that this entry is actually 'Dead by Daylight' with The Nightmare Before Christmas chapter. For true asymmetric horror, consider 'Friday the 13th: The Game' if still playable on legacy systems, but on PS5/Xbox, 'Dead by Daylight' remains the primary choice with this license.

More Related Lists to Explore
4
0

Hood: Outlaws & Legends

Visit

A four-player cooperative heist game with asymmetric elements where players steal from the rich. While less horror-focused, it offers stealth-based tension and betrayal mechanics that appeal to fans of high-stakes multiplayer dynamics.

5
0

Until Dawn: Rush of Blood

Visit

Though primarily a rollercoaster shooter, this VR/Non-VR hybrid experience shares DNA with asymmetrical horror design principles. It focuses on group survival and quick-time events, offering a lighter but still thrilling multiplayer horror alternative.

6
0

Phasmophobia

Visit

A 1-4 player co-op psychological horror game where players act as paranormal investigators. While not strictly asymmetric (everyone is a ghost hunter), the roles and tasks create a functional asymmetry in gameplay duties and required skills.

7
0

Demonologist

Visit

A recent addition to the co-op horror space where players take on distinct roles like Exorcist or Medium. The asymmetrical role distribution requires communication and coordination to exorcise demons in dynamically changing environments.

8
0

Lethal Company

Visit

A viral co-op horror hit where players scavenge moons for scrap while avoiding deadly creatures. The asymmetry comes from individual roles and equipment choices, with the terrifying AI-driven environment creating emergent, unscripted horror moments.

9
0

Content Warning

Visit

A multiplayer horror game focused on filming dangerous creatures for internet fame. It offers a unique twist on the genre by combining social media mechanics with co-op survival, creating a distinct asymmetric tension between risk and reward.

10
0

Backrooms: Escape Together

Visit

Players navigate the endless, liminal spaces of the Backrooms as a team. While cooperative, the varying monster behaviors and puzzle-solving requirements create a functional asymmetry in how different players contribute to group survival.

11
0

Devour

Visit

Four players must perform rituals to appease an ancient spirit before it kills everyone. The asymmetry is derived from the specific tasks each player must complete while being hunted, requiring precise teamwork and role adherence.

12
0

Sons of the Forest

Visit

The sequel to The Forest features asymmetric multiplayer where players can choose to play as different characters with unique skills. The survival horror elements are heightened by complex AI companions and unpredictable cannibal encounters.

13
0

The Outlast Trials

Visit

A co-op prequel to Outlast where players work in teams to survive terrifying experiments. Although cooperative, the intense psychological horror and distinct character roles create a strong sense of specialized duty and shared vulnerability.

14
0

Graveyard Keeper

Visit

This title is primarily a management sim. For accurate horror recommendations, replace with 'Mouthwashing' which is single-player. Instead, consider 'Identity V', a mobile-first asymmetric horror game also available on consoles in some regions, focusing on 4v1 gameplay.

15
0

Identity V

Visit

A 4v1 asymmetric horror game originally on mobile but accessible on consoles. Players choose between Survivors trying to escape and a Hunter trying to catch them, offering a fast-paced, chess-like horror experience.

16
0

The Dark Pictures Anthology: House of Ashes

Visit

While primarily a shared-story cinematic game, the multiplayer mode allows players to make conflicting decisions, creating a functional asymmetry in choices. The intense horror narrative and branching outcomes provide a unique social experience.

17
0

Until Dawn

Visit

A cinematic horror adventure where players make choices that determine survival. The multiplayer mode allows friends to collectively decide actions, creating a dynamic where individual preferences might conflict with group survival, adding a layer of social tension.

18
0

The Quarry

Visit

From the creators of Until Dawn, this game features a large cast of camp counselors being hunted. The multiplayer mode splits decision-making among friends, creating asymmetric moral dilemmas and survival strategies in a horror setting.

19
0

Invasion of the Body Snatchers: The Game

Visit

A recent asymmetric multiplayer game where humans must identify impostors among them. Similar to Among Us but with a horror theme and more complex mechanics, offering a blend of deduction and supernatural terror.

20
0

Project: Playtime

Visit

A free-to-play 7v1 asymmetric horror game where six players collect toys for a clown boss while one player controls the menacing Captain Foxy. It offers a distinct cartoon-horror aesthetic and engaging chase mechanics.