Sports & Athletes

Best Undrafted Free Agents in Super Bowl History

A curated list of exceptional football players who reached the pinnacle of the sport without being selected in the NFL Draft. These athletes overcame significant odds to become key contributors or champions in the Super Bowl, showcasing grit, talent, and determination.

ID: 996291
Items: 20
Total Votes: 0
Forks: 3
Disclosure: Some links are affiliate links. If you buy through them, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you, supporting our work without affecting our ratings.
Want to feature your product on this list?
Sponsorship

Get targeted exposure with custom position pinning and highlighted placement.

Contact Us
1
0

Ben Roethlisberger

Visit

The Steelers legend played 18 seasons and won two Super Bowls, never being drafted. His career defied logic as he started Super Bowl XL and XLIII, leading Pittsburgh to victories despite being unsigned out of college.

2
0

James Harrison

Visit

A dominant linebacker who won Super Bowl XL with Pittsburgh after going undrafted. Known for his intense pass rushing and a famous 100-yard return touchdown in the playoffs, he earned Super Bowl XL MVP honors for his clutch performances.

3
0

Jerod Mayo

The 2011 NFL Defensive Player of the Year won Super Bowl XLIX with the New England Patriots. Undrafted out of Tennessee, he became one of the league's most respected middle linebackers, known for his IQ and leadership on defense.

4
0

David Tyree

Visit

Best known for the 'Helmet Catch' in Super Bowl XLII, this wide receiver helped the Giants upset the undefeated Patriots. Undrafted in 2005, Tyree proved that clutch playmaking could overcome a lack of draft pedigree on the biggest stage.

5
0

Steve Atwater

A legendary safety who won Super Bowl XXII with the Denver Broncos. Undrafted in 1988, he became a defensive cornerstone in the NFL, earning multiple Pro Bowls and known for his hard-hitting style that defined the Broncos' defense of that era.

6
0

Tiki Barber

Visit

A highly productive running back for the New York Giants who won Super Bowl XXI. Undrafted in 1997, Barber built a Hall of Fame-caliber career with over 10,000 rushing yards, though he missed the Giants' later championship with a torn ACL.

7
0

BenJarvus Green-Ellis

Visit

Known as 'The Law Firm,' he was a workhorse back for the New England Patriots and won Super Bowl XLVI. Undrafted in 2009, he rushed for over 1,000 yards in his breakout season and was a crucial part of New England's ground-and-pound attack.

8
0

Matt Light

Visit

A reliable offensive tackle for the Patriots who won three Super Bowls. Undrafted in 2001, Light became a six-time Pro Bowl selection, anchoring the offensive line that protected Tom Brady and paved the way for New England's dynasty.

9
0

Josh Brown

Visit

A kicker who won Super Bowl XLVIII with the Seattle Seahawks. Undrafted out of Texas A&M-Commerce, Brown established himself as a clutch performer in the NFL, converting critical field goals throughout his career with Seattle and Washington.

10
0

Brian Urlacher

Visit

A Hall of Fame linebacker who won Super Bowl XLI with the Chicago Bears. Undrafted in 2000, Urlacher quickly became one of the most dynamic defenders in history, combining speed and power to dominate games and earn multiple Defensive Player of the Year awards.

11
0

Willie Roaf

Visit

While often debated due to draft position nuances, Roaf was a key undrafted-style pickup who became an offensive tackle Hall of Famer. He won Super Bowl XXIX with the 49ers and anchored the offensive line that supported Steve Young's championship runs.

12
0

Jared Allen

Visit

A ferocious pass rusher who won Super Bowl XLVIII with the Seattle Seahawks. Undrafted in 2004, Allen broke the NFL single-season sack record in 2011 and was a transformative force on the defensive line throughout his decade-long career.

13
0

Fred Smoot

Visit

A versatile defensive back who won Super Bowl XLIII with the Pittsburgh Steelers. Undrafted in 2003, Smoot was known for his big-play ability and coverage skills, contributing significantly to the Steelers' defense that shut down the Cardinals in the championship game.

14
0

Chris Kluwe

An punter who played for the Vikings and won a Super Bowl ring as a member of the 2006 Bears practice squad. While not a starter, his inclusion highlights the depth undrafted specialists can bring to a championship team's special teams unit.

15
0

Ryan Succop

Visit

A consistent kicker who won Super Bowl LI with the New England Patriots. Undrafted in 2009, Succop had a long career with the Chiefs, Buccaneers, and Patriots, known for his leg strength and reliability in high-pressure situations during regular seasons and playoffs.

16
0

Dwight Freeney

Visit

A dominant defensive end who won Super Bowl XLI with the Indianapolis Colts. Undrafted in 2002, Freeney became one of the most recognizable players in the league, recording over 100 sacks and setting the franchise record for sacks in a season.

17
0

La'Roi Glover

Visit

A powerful defensive tackle who won Super Bowl XXXVI with the New England Patriots. Undrafted in 1997, Glover was a key component of the Patriots' defense, using his size and strength to disrupt opposing offenses and anchor the interior line.

18
0

Johnathan Joseph

Visit

A shutdown cornerback who won Super Bowl XLVIII with the Seattle Seahawks. Undrafted in 2006, Joseph developed into one of the NFL's most reliable cover men, playing crucial roles for the Texans, Bengals, and Raiders before joining the Seahawks' defense.

19
0

Jermaine Lewis

Visit

A special teams star and returner who won four Super Bowls with the Baltimore Ravens. Undrafted in 1998, Lewis was instrumental in Baltimore's early success, known for his speed, vision, and ability to change games with his return skills.

20
0

Trent Dilfer

Visit

The quarterback who led the Ravens to Super Bowl XXXV victory. Undrafted in 1994, Dilfer proved that quarterbacking intelligence and team leadership could outweigh draft status, guiding a defense-dominated team to the championship with efficient play.