Underrated Mystery Series on Hulu with Shocking Plot Twists

A chilling true-crime drama that explores the manipulative relationship between Dee Dee Blanchard and her daughter Gypsy-Rose. The series delivers shocking revelations about abuse and deception, culminating in a twist that redefines the nature of the crime itself.

Based on Liane Moriarty's novel, this series follows nine guests at a health retreat whose lives take a dark turn. The narrative slowly unravels the sinister secrets behind the wellness center, offering multiple layers of deception and a finale filled with unexpected betrayals.

This adaptation of Celeste Ng's novel examines the collision of two families with different philosophies on life and motherhood. As secrets from the past come to light, the story builds to a fiery climax where the true nature of the characters' actions is fully revealed.

A gripping miniseries that traces the origins of the opioid crisis in America through the eyes of multiple stakeholders. The plot twists reveal the calculated greed of pharmaceutical executives, providing a harrowing look at how trust was exploited on a massive scale.

This psychological thriller flips the script by having a serial killer become the patient of the psychiatrist he plans to murder. The dynamic shifts power constantly, leading to a tense cat-and-mouse game where neither character is quite who they appear to be.

Three strangers share a passion for true crime podcasts and suddenly find themselves involved in a real death at their NYC apartment building. While popular, its intricate puzzle-box storytelling and red herrings offer significant twists that challenge the audience's assumptions until the very end.

Based on Jon Krakauer's book, this series follows an LAPD detective investigating a brutal murder within a fundamentalist Mormon community. The investigation uncovers disturbing truths about faith and fanaticism, with a twist that connects the personal to the systemic in a shocking way.

This limited series dramatizes the Robert Durst case, focusing on the Jimenez family who took in the accused murderer. The narrative carefully pieces together clues as the family realizes they are harboring a monster, leading to a chilling conclusion about complicity and silence.

While primarily a corporate drama, the series functions as a mystery about Elizabeth Holmes and Theranos. The audience watches the gradual exposure of a massive fraud, with twists revealing how much deception was possible before the truth inevitably came crashing down.

This series explores the scandal surrounding Pamela Anderson and Tommy Lee, but it twists the narrative to focus on the theft of their private tape. The plot reveals the cold, calculated nature of the cybercrime involved, challenging the public's perception of victimhood and consent.

Based on the true story of Michelle Carter, this series examines the text-message manslaughter case with gripping detail. It twists the traditional legal drama by focusing on the psychological manipulation behind the screen, revealing the disturbing depth of the relationship's toxicity.

This series investigates the murder of Betsy Faria and the subsequent false confession implicating her friend Pam Hupp. The plot twists as the investigation reveals a complex web of insurance fraud and manipulation, showing how two individuals conspired to frame an innocent woman.

A behind-the-scenes look at the making of The Godfather, it doubles as a thriller about the risks of producing a controversial film. The twists involve studio interference and creative clashes that mirror the tension within the films themselves, ending in a triumphant but chaotic release.

Ryan Murphy's limited series provides a harrowing look at the crimes of Jeffrey Dahmer and the systemic failures that allowed them to continue. The narrative twists focus on the victims and the detectives' persistence, delivering emotional shocks as the scale of the horror becomes clear.

This series re-examines the case of Michael Peterson, accused of murdering his wife. Through dual timelines, it reveals new evidence and testimonies that twist the original trial's narrative, leaving the audience questioning the guilt or innocence of the central figure until the final episode.

This series follows the rise and fall of Anna Delvey, who defrauded New York's elite with a fake inheritance story. The twists lie in the intersection of journalism, privilege, and deception, revealing how far the illusion went and the personal cost to those involved.

Based on a true story, this series follows a family terrorized by creepy letters from a fan known as 'The Watcher.' The mystery deepens as neighbors and family members become suspects, leading to a twist that challenges the viewer's perception of who is the real threat.

This series tells the true story of Candy Montgomery and her affair with her best friend's husband, which ended in a brutal attack. The narrative twists as it explores the domestic abuse and manipulation that led to the crime, challenging the simplicity of the initial murder charge.

A lesser-known series that follows a girl raised in the wilderness who returns to society. The mystery unfolds as she uncovers the dark reasons for her isolation, with twists that reveal a conspiracy involving government experiments and personal betrayal.

While critically acclaimed, this series remains a hidden gem for those who missed its intense psychological depth. The plot twists recontextualize every character's motive, offering a masterclass in misdirection that keeps the audience guessing until the identity of the killer is revealed.