Sports & Athletes

Greatest Underdog Comebacks in NFL Playoff History

A collection of the most miraculous and improbable victories in National Football League postseason history, featuring teams that overcame significant deficits against superior opponents. This list highlights clutch performances, strategic masterclasses, and moments of sheer resilience that defined careers and franchises.

ID: 73757
Items: 20
Total Votes: 0
Forks: 0
Disclosure: Some links are affiliate links. If you buy through them, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you, supporting our work without affecting our ratings.
Want to feature your product on this list?
Sponsorship

Get targeted exposure with custom position pinning and highlighted placement.

Contact Us
1
0

The 2017 Philadelphia Eagles vs. New Orleans Saints (NFC Divisional Round)

Visit

After trailing by 19 points late in the fourth quarter, the Eagles rallied behind a critical fumble recovery by Jay Ajayi. They converted a game-winning drive, showcasing extraordinary mental toughness against a high-powered Saints offense in a historic NFC Divisional Round upset.

2
0

The 2016 Green Bay Packers vs. Dallas Cowboys (NFC Wild Card)

Visit

Trailing by 13 points with under five minutes remaining, Aaron Rodgers led a 75-yard touchdown drive to tie the game. In overtime, Mason Crosby kicked the winning field goal, completing one of the most dramatic comebacks in recent postseason history.

3
0

The 2012 New York Giants vs. San Francisco 49ers (Super Bowl XLVI)

Visit

Facing a dominant 49ers defense and offense, Eli Manning threw for 340 yards and three touchdowns. The Giants held the NFL's top-ranked offense to just one touchdown, securing a 21-17 victory and validating their status as unlikely champions.

4
0

The 2011 New York Giants vs. Atlanta Falcons (Super Bowl XLV)

Visit

Note: This entry is corrected to the 2010 Giants vs. Patriots Super Bowl XLVI. The Giants trailed by 6 points with 1:50 left. Eli Manning engineered a drive culminating in a Victor Cruz touchdown pass, followed by a fake spike play to seal the win against the undefeated Patriots.

5
0

The 1970 Baltimore Colts vs. Oakland Raiders (Super Bowl III)

Visit

In a landmark upset, the AFL's New York Jets defeated the heavily favored NFL champion Baltimore Colts. Joe Namath's guarantee and performance proved that the newer league could compete with the established NFL, changing the landscape of professional football forever.

6
0

The 2001 St. Louis Rams vs. Philadelphia Eagles (NFC Divisional Round)

Visit

Despite injuries to key players, the Rams' 'Greatest Show on Turf' struggled initially. However, Kurt Warner threw for over 400 yards, and the team overcame a stiff Eagles defense to advance, demonstrating resilience despite not being the clear favorite entering the game.

7
0

The 2018 New England Patriots vs. Pittsburgh Steelers (Divisional Round)

Visit

Facing elimination after blowing a large lead in the previous round, the Patriots used a late touchdown pass to Daniel Jeremiah to force overtime. They then won the coin toss and drove for a game-winning field goal in freezing conditions, securing their 11th AFC Championship appearance.

8
0

The 2012 Baltimore Ravens vs. Denver Broncos (Divisional Round)

Visit

Trailing by 24 points early in the second half, the Ravens mounted a furious rally behind Ray Rice and Joe Flacco. They won on a last-second field goal, showcasing one of the largest second-half comebacks in NFL playoff history against a potent Broncos offense.

9
0

The 2000 St. Louis Rams vs. Minnesota Vikings (Divisional Round)

Visit

The Rams trailed by 14 points in the fourth quarter before kicker Morten Andersen booted three field goals in the final minutes. The comeback set up a Super Bowl appearance, highlighting the team's ability to win close, gritty games in the postseason.

10
0

The 2014 Carolina Panthers vs. Arizona Cardinals (NFC Divisional Round)

Visit

After losing a star quarterback, the Panthers relied on their defense and running game to upset the Cardinals. Cam Newton threw for two touchdowns, and the team defended a lead against a high-scoring opponent, proving that a balanced attack could overcome significant roster limitations.

11
0

The 2015 Seattle Seahawks vs. Green Bay Packers (NFC Divisional Round)

Visit

Although the Seahawks were the higher seed, they faced a dangerous Packers team. The game was decided by a controversial interception late in the game, but the Seahawks' defense held firm. The victory showcased their ability to win crucial playoff moments under pressure.

12
0

The 2019 San Francisco 49ers vs. Minnesota Vikings (Divisional Round)

Visit

Trailing by 10 points in the final minutes, Jimmy Garoppolo led a drive that ended with a touchdown pass to George Kittle. The 49ers then stopped the Vikings on a critical fourth-down play in overtime, securing a dramatic victory in a cold-weather playoff battle.

13
0

The 2020 Kansas City Chiefs vs. Tennessee Titans (Divisional Round)

Visit

Chad Henne, filling in for the injured Patrick Mahomes, threw for 383 yards and three touchdowns. The Chiefs overcame a gritty Titans defense to advance, highlighting the depth and adaptability required to succeed in the high-stakes NFL postseason.

14
0

The 2021 Green Bay Packers vs. Dallas Cowboys (Wild Card)

Visit

Jordan Love stepped in for an injured Aaron Rodgers and led the Packers to a crucial victory. The team overcame defensive struggles from the Cowboys to win 48-32, showcasing the resilience of the organization and the potential of young talent in critical moments.

15
0

The 2022 Tampa Bay Buccaneers vs. Los Angeles Rams (Wild Card)

Visit

Tom Brady led the Buccaneers to a 31-30 victory against the Rams' high-powered offense. A late touchdown pass to Chris Godwin secured the win, demonstrating Brady's enduring ability to perform under pressure and lead unlikely playoff victories late in his career.

16
0

The 2023 Detroit Lions vs. Los Angeles Rams (Wild Card)

Visit

The Lions won their first playoff game in decades with a dominant defensive performance. They overcame the Rams' offensive schemes by stifling key players, marking a historic turnaround for the franchise and proving their status as legitimate contenders in the NFC.

17
0

The 2018 Los Angeles Chargers vs. New England Patriots (Wild Card)

Visit

The Chargers nearly upset the heavily favored Patriots in a close game. Although they lost on a last-second field goal, their competitive performance against the top seed was considered an underdog success story, showcasing their resilience and competitive spirit in the postseason.

18
0

The 2013 New York Giants vs. Philadelphia Eagles (NFC Divisional Round)

Visit

Eli Manning threw for over 300 yards as the Giants upset the top-seeded Eagles. The victory highlighted the Giants' offensive efficiency and ability to execute under pressure, advancing them to the NFC Championship game in a surprising playoff run.

19
0

The 2006 Chicago Bears vs. New York Giants (NFC Divisional Round)

Visit

The Bears, known for their dominant defense, held the Giants to a field goal in a low-scoring affair. They advanced to the Super Bowl by shutting down a potent offense, demonstrating how defensive excellence can overcome offensive disparities in playoff baseball.

20
0

The 2017 New England Patriots vs. Pittsburgh Steelers (Divisional Round)

Visit

In freezing conditions, the Patriots defeated the Steelers on a last-second field goal. The game featured multiple lead changes and critical defensive stops, highlighting the Patriots' ability to win ugly and close out games in extreme weather during the playoffs.