A curated collection of the most dramatic, high-stakes overtime games in NFL postseason history. This list highlights the legendary performances, heartbreaking losses, and game-winning drives that defined eras and cemented players as legends of the sport.
Get targeted exposure with custom position pinning and highlighted placement.
Featuring the greatest comeback in Super Bowl history, this game ended in the first-ever Super Bowl overtime. James White scored the winning touchdown, capping a 28-3 deficit reversal that solidified Tom Brady's legacy.
A brutal divisional clash that stretched into overtime in freezing temperatures. Green Bay secured a victory with a clutch field goal, punching their ticket to the Super Bowl and continuing their dominance in the NFC North.
A defensive struggle that pushed into overtime for the second time in Super Bowl history. Patrick Mahomes led a precision drive ending in a game-winning touchdown catch by Mecole Hardman to secure a repeat championship.
An offensive explosion featuring Joe Burrow and Patrick Mahomes. The game reached a fever pitch in overtime, where the Bengals' defense finally stopped the Chiefs to secure a historic trip to the AFC Championship.
A classic early 90s battle defined by physical play and strategic field position. Washington utilized a grinding rushing attack to wear down the Lions before sealing the overtime victory to advance to Super Bowl XXVI.
A high-scoring shootout that saw Patrick Mahomes lead several late drives. The game ended in overtime when Adam Andy Gano kicked a field goal, marking a pivotal moment in the modern Chiefs-Patriots rivalry.
Peyton Manning showcased his legendary precision in a tight contest that went the distance. The Colts eventually prevailed in overtime, demonstrating the offensive potency that defined the Manning era in Indianapolis.
Known for its dramatic swings, this game saw the Cardinals overcome a late Packers surge. Arizona eventually secured the overtime win, marking one of the most exciting playoff games of the mid-2010s.
A clash of titans between two of the era's greatest defenses. The 49ers managed to find the end zone in overtime, securing their spot in the Super Bowl and continuing their 80s-90s dynasty.
Though technically decided in the final seconds of regulation, this game is often grouped with overtime thrillers due to the '13 Seconds' miracle. It remains one of the most stressful finishes in NFL history.